User talk:Angusmclellan/Archive 3April 2006 to June 2006 Owains of Strathclyde !
That's cool, I started dabbing to the appropriate Owains on pages that linked to Owain of Strathclyde.--Cúchullain t/c 20:12, 21 April 2006 (UTC) I'll have done Owen the Bald in a few hours. I need to do Máel Coluim I first though. BTW, does Duncan mention anything about Máel Coluim II? I have Oram and Broun arguing for his existence, so a Duncan reference would seal the deal on his article. - Calgacus (ΚΑΛΓΑΚΟΣ) 20:22, 21 April 2006 (UTC)
Viceroys of New SpainThanks so much for the kind words, Angus. I have three very good sources in Spanish, and I've just been reading those, then writing new articles in English. Unfortunately, though, my sources cover only Mexican viceroys. What information there is on the viceroys of Peru was already there before I added information, or was sketchily mentioned in passing in my sources. I would like to write on them too, but there is no more about them in Mexico (where I live) then there is in the U.S. (where I'm from). Oh well, maybe I'll get to Peru sometime. Rbraunwa 17:29, 2 May 2006 (UTC) I am surpised that this article is not protected from edit wars. It's a hot button subject. - Sal 09:51, 4 May 2006 (UTC) I think that your recent edit on the Armenian Genocide opposition section was fair though I think the comment that few of these historians considered as authorities is highly disputable. But I am Ok with letting the facts speak for themselves and I'm not going to dispute this charecterization. There's small typo in your edit: In the second line "cconsider" needs to be corrected. I did so many recent edits, I hesitate do another one. If you find the time, article might benefit from fixing this typo. Thanks for contributing to the discussion. Best Deepblue06 MacWilliams & MacHethsYou beat me to it. The thing preventing me doing these articles was that I still haven't worked out the early MacHeths, since Oram says something completely different from everyone else, but doesn't resolve the problems he creates. BTW, can you give me a few days to do Harald Maddadsson; I got the SHR article and other stuff in order to write it. BTW, since you're now taking an interest in the High Medieval stuff (the most fascinating period in Scottish history in my opinion), do you have any thoughts of changing the titles of the Mormaers from X n of Y, to X n, Earl of Y. Totally against the X, n Earl of Y, because it is totally inappropriate for lords of this kind. I based my titling of these articles on the French and German aristocracy on wiki, where X n of Y is common. - 12:21, 14 May 2006 (UTC) —The preceding unsigned comment was added by Calgacus (talk • contribs) .
Hi, just to warn you that I will RfAr todayIf you want to prepare a speech in the RfAr and have time right now, do it so, because this time I'm afraid I have to do it. You will hit your head on a wall if you read all the evidences I have accumulated and what can be concluded from it. Fad (ix) 16:56, 20 May 2006 (UTC)
de la ReynieMost excellent improvements to old de la Reynie -- "..economic police(?); manners(?)" => "trade and public decency" -- sounds so much better! And many thanks for the missing paragraph as well. Now if only we can get the Murchads and Flaithbertachs sorted out we'll be golden :) Bookgrrl 19:24, 21 May 2006 (UTC) For your historical contributions
Translation of fr:Jean Louis de Nogaret de La ValetteDidnt realize you had this one staked out, looks like I accidentally beat you to it, though at the moment I cant recall how or why I ended up doing this one...o wot a tangled web we weave when first we begin to wiki... --Bookgrrl 02:29, 23 May 2006 (UTC) Chew Valley FACThanks for your conditional support of Chew Valley for FA status, I've removed the majority of "include/includes/including X, Y, Z" as you suggested & would be grateful if you'd take a look & see if this has addressed your concerns? Rod 13:02, 23 May 2006 (UTC)
Hi Angus. As you had said in the deletion debate you would rewrite the article if it were kept, I have put a copy of what was there at Ivy Close/temp. If you are able to rewrite using the extra sources etc you found, it can then go back into Ivy Close (which has been deleted in its current state). Then tag the temp page for speedy deletion. Let me know if you have any questions. Regards, Proto||type 13:19, 23 May 2006 (UTC)
Have you been having problems too?http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Requests_for_comment/Karatekid7 —The preceding unsigned comment was added by BiII the Bear (talk • contribs) . New cat: what's the point?Angus, what do you make of this new Category:Scottish Catholics? I cannot say that I am too impressed: 99% of notable pre-Reformation Scots, and thousands of notable post-Reformation Scots were Catholcs. If there are thousands of relevant biography articles that can be put in there, what on earth is the use of the cat? I nearly CFD'd it last night, but went to bed instead. (I must be grumpy lately: I have seen several things recently that I thought ought to be AFD's or CFD'd, which is unusual, cos I am certainly an inclusionist.) I may be wrong, so would value a 2nd (and 3rd, 4th, 5th... etc) opinion.--Mais oui! 09:03, 1 June 2006 (UTC)
Hello, can you quote any source regarding your last edit at Charlie Burchill ? Brian W 11:30, 1 June 2006 (UTC) . RE: Piece of NonsenseYeah, 'tis nonsense. But he moved the pages, and then visited the old page, edited it why a null redirect so that it couldn't be moved back. Now I have to go around moving Mormaer pages pages to "Earl" pages, which is fine for later on, but doesn't make that much sense for, say, Dubdon of Atholl. There's so many to change, that it'll prolly take lots of time to fix the redirects and page links. - Calgacus (ΚΑΛΓΑΚΟΣ) 17:45, 1 June 2006 (UTC)
Clearly, you medievalists have not bothered with discussions about guidelines, and now you start to be unhappy when people put articles under titles they actually are supposed to be under. Look upwards your this talkpage, I informed you that soon medieval ladies will have "Princess" titles. That's something I feel strongly, against. I am not so bothered with earls and so forth, as they actually were then or at least retrospectively called earls. But have you done anything for preventing medieval ladies to get princess... Soon there will be Princess Bethoc of Scotland and Princess Gruoch of Moray, or something like that. ObRoy 18:46, 1 June 2006 (UTC)
move of Gillacomgain of Morayif you are intending to move Gilla Coemgáin of Moray, please open first a discussion at its talkpage, and then wait for results until any move is made. I believe his naming will be a more complex issue than the routine ones. Marrtel 23:25, 2 June 2006 (UTC)
Robert the BruceWell, Angus, I simply grew up knowing he was a Catholic to be honest, and the fact his life was spent before the Reformation always led me to think of him as a Catholic of course, as well as all the other Scottish monarchs until John Knox's arrival, and even afterwards (we all know the House of Stuart was almost entirely Catholic, with some striking exceptions who should be considered). If you feel it is wrong to have the Bruce under the Catholic category, feel free to erase him. We will discuss about it later on, when I'll start adding all the Catholic Scottish monarchs quoting the source of course. Bye! Gianmaria Framarin 2:59 3 June 2006 Burns: I was surprised as wellDear Angus, I quoted the source on Robert Burns entirely on his section: I have Scottish Protestant relatives from Ayr, and though I always knew he was a strong anti-Calvinist I couldn't really imagine he was also a Catholic. Please check the quote, and feel free to do whatever you please. On the other hand, there are some Scottish monarchs who were outspoken Catholics (as I had said, almost all the House of Stuart), you will already find these monarchs (James I, II, III and so on onto Mary of course) under the category "Roman Catholics" (which I didn't create), and I wouldn't dare denying this myself (what would William Wallace be then?). I will probably find some resistance in quoting pre-Reformation figures, but I don't think I'll find any speaking of outspoken Catholic and Jacobite kings. Bye. Gianmaria Framarin 3:27 3 June 2006 Categorising people by religionI'll get back to you on this, prob tommorrow (something just came up - like you I spend my working life waiting for things to go wrong). First thoughts: we perhaps should look at the wider picture: ie. this is not a Scotland-only phenomenon (mis-spelt). "All that stub cat stuff you did today has got me started on unstubbing some of the easier candidates". Excellent! That is indeed the whole point: ideal number of stubs and stub cats = zero. Je renvoie Illegitimi non carborundum. --Mais oui! 21:46, 3 June 2006 (UTC)
I guess the Armenian Genocide Article/issue is too much for you to manageBased on your input/commentary I had some hopes for you. But you made a few good points - ran face to face with the ugly and persistent denial that we have to deal with every day - and you scampered off...shall we call you Sir Robin? --THOTH 05:06, 4 June 2006 (UTC) Manic OverlinkingI'm kinda new at this, so if you can point me to some general guidelines on linking, I'd appreciate it Hobomojo 22:22, 4 June 2006 (UTC)
Put me out of my miseryGreen ink would suit. Nope, you lost me there. Sorry to show my ignorance but where does the green ink reference fit in ? -- Derek Ross | Talk 23:40, 5 June 2006 (UTC) GeniusJudging fan films by the porn test. That's pure genius. Ha ha! -- GWO
Irish StubsI've added a few more stubs, and hope to have a few more done before too long. Nothing too adventerious, but hopefully of interest. Knock yourself out. Fergananim 17:47, 8 June 2006 (UTC)
Re: advice on Maison du RoiIt looks to me that the en-wiki article Maison du Roi is too focused on the military division, while the fr-wiki, on the other hand, seems to be scattered over too many pages (Maison du roi, Département de la Maison du roi, Grand office de la Maison du roi de France, etc.). Instead of doing an isolated translation of the "département" page, I might make (depending on size of the page... you can always break into separate pages later) a major revision to Maison du Roi, with divisions into civil, military, ecclesiastical and ministerial (putting under this latter heading the département information, with "Ministry of the Maison du roi" as a possible translation of "départment"). To help you in the task, see the presentation on the fr-wiki "Maison du roi". Additionally, I would make sure that Early Modern France (the section on the structure of the Ancien Régime) has a good link to these governmental/royal articles. That's my 2 cents, anyway. Also, I don't know if you're interested, but feel free to join and/or promote the Wikipedia:France-related topics notice board. Thanks for keeping up the good work! Cheers- --NYArtsnWords 22:58, 8 June 2006 (UTC) Anglicanism and the Anglican CommunionHello! I noticed that you have been a contributor to articles on Anglicanism and the Anglican Communion. You may be interested in checking out a new WikiProject - WikiProject Anglicanism. Please consider signing up and participating in this collaborative effort to improve and expand Anglican-related articles! Cheers! Fishhead64 22:46, 11 June 2006 (UTC)
Polish medieval monarchs namingHi. I have proposed to move the following monarchs from their current, generally Polish-spelled names (with diacriticals) to the systematical English name, citing my general ground that English should be used, not Polish. Would you share your opinion at Talk:Bolesław I the Brave , Talk:Bolesław II the Bold, Talk:Mieszko II Lambert, Talk:Władysław III Spindleshanks, Talk:Jan I Olbracht and Talk:Kazimierz III the Great. Marrtel 19:39, 12 June 2006 (UTC) Colman mac Suibni"Quick question: Frank Byrne refers to the Clann Cholmáin king Conall son of Suibne (died 635) as Colman Guthbinn. Is that still current os should I say Colman mac Suibni ? Also, other than Mide, was he king of ? Uisnech I'd guess." Actually I'm not too sure on either of these, so I'll have to look them up, health permitting. A way around it would be to call any article on him as Colman mac Suibni, but place AKA Colman Guthbinn in the explanatory heading. Not too sure of the exact range of his kingdom/s, either. A good person to ask would be User:Aine nic, who, despite being a redmark user, seems to have some interesting material to back her up. I think she could fit into our informal medieval group very nicely. Keep up the good work! Fergananim 11:45, 13 June 2006 (UTC) **** YOU!!!Dammit, the Flann Sinna article is brilliant! You sicken me! Right, I'm handing in my long-article volunteer status to Wiki, and will stick to wee stubs I have the health and patience for. Seriously though, it is a damm fine job, far and away the best I have yet seen on any Irish leader prior to Daniel O'Connell. As to the book of Leinster I have some interesting material on it, but I've noticed a few errors in the source, so I'm going to spend some time double-checking it. Mostly what I think I'll be doing from now on will be thrawling through academic articles and condesnseing them for individual articles. Some of them, even those recently published, are very obscure to most people but are far more up-to-date and interesting that generalised histories. Its sure a nice way to spend an otherwise unbearable day. Will get back to you on these. Meanwhile, here's a quick list of my other additions, which I humbly offer for your edification.
Really want to set the scene for my favorite poet of the 10th century, the notoriousFlann mac Lonáin. You'll love him! Fergananim 12:39, 13 June 2006 (UTC) Just a few queries: 1 - Flann's mother was called Land? Do you mean Fland, or indeed Flann, which was a name used for both sexes? 2 - His children; list them all in order, instead of later introducing Gormlaith seperatly from the male offspring. Might not be a bad idea to revise the "Family" paragraph so as to make it read more smoothly. 3 - In the "Reign" section;
That's about it. Interesting, the relationship between Mide and Connacht in those times, as Mide was entering its apex of power and could dictate to Connacht. Later on, during the reign of Tairrdelbach mac Ruaidri Ua Conchobair, Mide was frequently cut up to serve Connacht's interests, so much so that it was reguarded as annexed to, and thus part of, Connacht. The kingdom came to an inglourious end with the murder of Domnall Bregach Ua Mael Sechlainn in 1173; however, it did enjoy a brief and savage twilight under Cormac mac Art O Melaghlain who nevertheless died in Connacht, showing just what a strong part the latter kingdom played in the "special relationship" that had developed between the two. Keep up the good work, you don't know how delighted I am to see someone writing articles of this quality on these subjects! Fergananim 20:12, 13 June 2006 (UTC) Hi Angus. Thanks for the welcome. Well done on Flann Sinna; most of my changes were to the family section. I'm afraid my HTML skills are, umm, nascent, so I think I screwed up some of your formatting. Apologies. Am a bit distracted at the moment by being in (false) pre-labour with first child. |